The Torah's ethos of punishment

This write-up highlights the Torah's philosophy to punishment, namely, that its aim is to provide justice, rehabilitation and prevention—not dehumanization and debasement. 

In two places, both in Ki Seitzei, the Torah discusses a reality where the demands of justice require a corporal response and yet in both places emphasizes the need to preserve human dignity and that the punishment not spill over into unnecessary degradation and the stripping away of the offender's humanity. 

In both cases the Torah employs a word root that bespeaks dishonor and ignominy—קל(ל)ה—to describe the debasement it seeks to avoid.

The first (Devarim 21:22-23) centers on where a person need be hung (either as deterrence [Chazal]), or to kill him [e.g., Qumran text, Peshitta]), with the Torah cautioning that it not be overdone, as that will result in unnecessarily mortifying debasement—כִּי קִלְלַת אֱלֹהִים תָּלוּי (,הגר"א דברים כ"א:כ"ג: כי קללת אלהים תלוי – אלהים הוא להפליג הדבר כמו הררי אל שלהבת יה וכן כאן פירושו בזיון גדול מופלג מאוד והוא בזיון התליה כי קללה הוא לשון בזיון בכל מקום.).

The second (ibid 25:2-3) is where a person is determined to be liable for lashes with the Torah specifying that it not be overdone as that will result in your brother's debasement—וְנִקְלָה אָחִיךָ לְעֵינֶיךָ  (תרגום אונקלוס, דברים כ"ה:ג': אַרְבְּעִין יַלְקֵינֵיהּ לָא יוֹסֵיף דִּלְמָא יוֹסֵיף לְאַלְקָיוּתֵיהּ עַל אִלֵּין מַחָא רַבָּא וְיֵיקַל אֲחוּךְ לְעֵינָךְ.). 

The Torah articulates the idea that punishment is not a tool to obliterate a person's basic respect and humanity but rather to serve justice, rehabilitate the offender and prevent others from engaging in similar behavior.

It is expressing the concept that punishment be executed in as dignified a manner as possible. 

Utmost care need be taken, especially when justice mandates someone's whipping/hanging, that it be administered with discernment and not result in the person's humanity being devalued.

(Chazal even read into the verse that should the prescribed lashes cause the person to be overly embarrassed, that the whipping be prematurely terminated: ספרי דברים, כ"ה:ג': ונקלה אחיך לעיניך – מיכן אמרו נתקלקל בין ברעי בין במים פטור, emphasizing the Torah's concern for human dignity—even a sinner's)

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Sukkos: Pesach in the fall

This piece attempts to uncover an entirely new way of looking at the significance of Sukkos in what essentially amounts to a paradigm shift about the chag Vayikra 23:42-43 בַּסֻּכֹּת תֵּשְׁבוּ שִׁבְעַת יָמִים כׇּל הָאֶזְרָח בְּיִשְׂרָאֵל יֵשְׁבוּ בַּסֻּכֹּת. לְמַעַן יֵדְעוּ דֹרֹתֵיכֶם כִּי בַסֻּכּוֹת הוֹשַׁבְתִּי אֶת בְּנֵי יִשְׂרָאֵל בְּהוֹצִיאִי אוֹתָם מֵאֶרֶץ מִצְרָיִם אֲנִי י"י אֱלֹהֵיכֶם. There is no other biblical record of our forefathers ever having stayed in booths in the aftermath of the Exodus. The rishonim (ad loc) quote a disagreement (bavli sukkah 11b) between R Eliezer and R Akiva as to the identity of the pasuk's obscure referent: כי בסכות הושבתי – איזו סכות היו, ר' אליעזר אומר ענני כבוד היו, ר' עקיבא אומר, סכות ממש then saying that it works out acc to R Eliezer but acc to R Akiva what exactly are we celebrating?; see there for various solutions. The rishonim have in common an understanding that the holiday is somehow related to hitherto unmentioned boo...
Read more

The Miracle Gap: Pesach Without Krias Yam Suf

The Torah doesn't provide a date for the splitting of the sea.  Chazal (e.g., Seder Olam Rabbah 5 ), however, place krias yam suf on the last day of Pesach (cited by Rashi to Shemos 14:5 ).  Seforno ( Vayikrah 23:36 , Devarim 16:8 ) sees the song that Israel engaged in together in praise of HaShem for that event as what imbued shevii shel pesach with the status of a Yom Tov.  People tend to view Pesach as getting started with the Exodus on the 15th (the catalyst for the first day being a YT) and culminating seven days later with krias yam suf, when the Egyptians were fully removed from the picture, thus completing Israel's salvation from the Egyptians.  However, in Rambam's telling, Pesach seems to be exclusively a celebration of the miracles that happened in Egypt and the Exodus, but nothing thereafter, significantly altering Pesach's character. In MT ( Chametz uMatzah, 7:1-2 ), Rambam is clear that the mitzvah of retelling the Exodus account is limited to the mirac...
Read more

Rambam’s Shofar: A Call to the Heart, Not to the Heavens

Rambam writes (e.g.,  Sefer Hamitzvos , Mishneh Torah ) that the mitzvah of shofar lies in hearing it—not in sounding it.  That's to say that men don't have an obligation to blow the shofar individually (which would only be fulfilled via שומע כתוקע if one is listening to another sound it*) but rather simply to listen to the sound of the shofar (with the caveat that it is blown by someone similarly obligated as well as both the blower and hearer intentionally thinking about connecting with the other).  The bracha recited prior to mitzvas shofar is formulated in Mishneh Torah to reflect that conceptualization with the nusach לשמוע—not לתקוע.  Of course there's also Rambam's famous lesson on introspection that the Shofar alludes to which too is about what we hear (and internalize)—not what we project to others (also referenced  in the Guide to the Perplexed )**.  Halachic rationale aside perhaps this is (also) Rambam following his philosophical beliefs....
Read more