The Heart of the Matter

Plainly, Leah thought she was to be Yaakov's only wife and the one for whom he had lovingly labored for seven years (see here). She must have been devastated when, after just one week of marriage, her husband ups and marries her younger sister Rachel. Inevitably, the crushing realization sets in that Yaakov's heart belongs to Rachel, not her.

God sees her anguish and grants her a child. Leah names him Reuven to reflect that: "Because Hashem has seen my affliction. Surely, now, my husband will love me." Another quickly follows, whom she similarly names Shimon: "Because Hashem has heard that I am hated and has given me this one, too." Then another follows, whom she names Levi: "Now, this time, my husband will attach himself to me, for I have borne him three sons." This reflects her growing confidence that Yaakov will finally warm toward her, as she is providing him with so many sons, something Rachel has not been able to do.

When she has a fourth, she is sure it will do the trick. Full of praise to God, she names him Yehuda accordingly: "This time I will thank Hashem," convinced that this will finally win Yaakov over. Still riding high when Zilpah's two sons arrive, she names them Gad and Asher, respectively ("Good fortune has arrived"; "In my happiness, for women have deemed me happy").

As time passes, however, the nagging realization begins to fester: she is still not the favorite wife, or even on par with Rachel. She has been deluding herself and in denial all this time. This is pathetically manifest in her tortured response to Rachel's request for some flowers: "Is it not enough that you took my husband, that you would take also my son's mandrakes?" Rachel agrees to relinquish Yaakov to her for the night, after which Leah gives birth to her fifth child, whom she names Yissachar.

A sixth and final son comes along, and it is in his name, Zevulun ("God has given me a good gift; this time my husband will dwell with me, for I have borne him six sons"), that it becomes clear she is still pining for her husband's love and attention, hoping and praying that the large number of sons she has borne him will finally prevail upon him and win him over to her.

Which never happens.

For it was never about which sister could provide him with more children, but rather which sister had his heart as a woman. Rachel's comeliness stole the show, and that was not something Leah could overcome with numerous offspring. This is an extremely difficult reality to come to terms with, as it would mean recognizing her own inferiority relative to her pretty younger sister, along with her own inability to do anything about it. It is emotionally much easier for Leah to believe that, whatever the issue is, it is something she can overcome by providing him with many sons. 

A hope that never materializes.

Comments

  1. Please see my comment on your previous piece. All I will add here is that the preference Yaakov showed to Rachel was primarily because the part of כלל ישראל that was supposed to come from her were the Kohanim, the spiritual foundation, while the part that was supposed to come from Leah was the part that Yitzchok envisioned coming from Eisav, the Melachim (kings) who oversaw the physical needs of the nation. When Yaakov took over both parts (by taking the blessings intended for Eisav), he had to marry Leah too, but that didn't mean he had to consider the physical branch more important than the spiritual branch, so Rachel remained his "primary" wife.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Rambam’s Shofar: A Call to the Heart, Not to the Heavens

Sukkos: Pesach in the fall

Gilgul and the Bavli